Meine Liebe 226q65 Eien naru Traumerei

ALLZ

Meine Liebe - Eien naru Traumerei

to add items to your list, keep track of your progress, and rate series!

Description

Erika Klause was separated from her brother when she was little. Determined to meet him, she decides to enroll at Rosenstolz Academy, where she is sure that she will find him. But, on the first day of school, she accidentally meets the five Strahl candidates. Since assistants of the Strahl candidates gain access to the boys' dormitories, Erika becomes determined to become an assistant in order to find her long lost brother. What awaits Erika at Rosenstolz Academy? 3c6w2o

Yuki Kaori only did the original character designs.

Type

Manga

Related Series

N/A

Associated Names

Meine Liebe

Meine Liebe (German)

Meine Liebe - Eien naru Musoukyoku

Meine Liebe - Eien naru Musoukyoku (Traumerei)

Meine Liebe - Eien naru Träumerei

Meine Liebe - The Neverending Traumerei

Meine Liebe 0 Giấc mơ vĩnh hằng

Min elskede (Danish)

My Love (Meine Liebe)

حُبي

マイネリーベ ―永遠なる夢想曲

我的摯愛 ~永遠的夢幻曲~

永远的梦想曲

耽美梦想

Groups Scanlating

A Willful Muse

Kagami

The Meine Liebe Project

Latest Release(s)

v.4 c.10-11 (end) by A Willful Muse 17 years ago

v.2 + 4 c. by The Meine Liebe Project 17 years ago

v.3 c.9b by The Meine Liebe Project 17 years ago

Search for all releases of this series

Status in Country of Origin

4 Volumes (Complete)

Completely Scanlated?

Yes

Anime Start/End Chapter

Starts at Vol 1, Chap 1

Ends at

Reviews

Meine Liebe by Akari

Forum

1 topics, 2 posts

Click here to view the forum

Rating

Average: 6.6 / 10.0 (195 votes)

Bayesian Average: 6.56 / 10.0

14%

10%

21%

17%

11%

Last Updated

February 26th, 2022 3:09am PST - 3 years ago

Image [Report Inappropriate Content]

Genre

Search for series of same genre(s)

Categories

to vote! Show all (some hidden)

Category Recommendations

Hadaka no Ouji-sama - Love Kingdom

Hakuouki (HIRAKU Naki)

Will o' Wisp

Hiiro no Kakera - Ni no Shou (Novel)

Kiniro no Corda - Blue Sky

Recommendations

Shiawase Kissa 3-choume

Ore-sama Teacher

Vampire Knight

Merupuri

Emma

Author(s)

IZAWA Rei

Artist(s)

IZAWA Rei

YUKI Kaori

Year

2005

Original Publisher

Hakusensha

Serialized In (magazine)

Bessatsu Hana to Yume (Hakusensha)

Licensed (in English)

English Publisher

Chuang Yi (4 Volumes - Complete)

Activity Stats (vs. other series)

(-42)

(-138)

(-1071)

6 Month Pos #4998 (No change)

(+180)

List Stats

On 293 reading lists

On 385 wish lists

On 794 completed lists

On 56 unfinished lists

On 167 custom lists

Note: You must be logged in to update information on this page.

Forum Posts Click to view the forum

What's your ideal Meine Liebe plot?

12 years ago

Comments [ Order by usefulness ]

Ok ish

by happygem
10 years ago

Rating: 7.0 / 10.0

So~ I enjoyed it. A nice pickup. This story is mostly about the girl finding the brother, though in the beginning I already had the feeling it would be that person, and in the end it's really him but the story made it so that you will doubt your premonition, it's enjoyable, the suspense of knowing who the brother is once and for all.

but I don't get why Ed and Erika are of the same age, and Ed being the older brother but he's born later than Erika. Ed in July, Erika in January and they're both 17. They were said to be half siblings but towards the end it felt like they share the same mother, when the stepmother was scolding them in chapter 10 I think, so the father had relationship with two or three women? yuck

Was this comment useful?

Not for the fans of the ML anime

by Suiren-nyan
12 years ago

Rating: 2.0 / 10.0

I love the Meine Liebe anime and picked the manga to learn more about my favorite characters. Umm. No, thank you.

As Doki wrote: "the Strahl seem OOC and the manga does not devote a great deal to their character development, barely touching on what makes them unique"

Totally agreed. For example, Camus, my favorite character of the anime, is never spiteful of anyone, while in the manga he complains to the heroine that others mock him because of his unique ability (so she can comfort him and show how special and tolerant she is -_- ). I find both the manga and the games to be a different universe than the anime (there is more: for example, in the second ML game Camus's older brother has a dofferent name than in the anime, etc.)

While the Meine Liebe anime is about friendship, male camaraderie, overcoming one's flaws, growing up, etc. (it really moves me at times), the manga is very shallow. The heroine is super banal and annoying (and yes, like others already mentioned, she trips A LOT). I think the only good thing about this manga is the art.

Was this comment useful?

All visuals, little substance.

by Hanjae
13 years ago

Rating: 7.0 / 10.0

I'm really of two minds what I should say about Meine Liebe. Objectively, it had a potentially interesting plot and cast of characters that wanted development, as well as including every romance novel and otome game cliché in the book. We were teased with brief glimpses of some rather fascinating characters, like Ludwig, but they faded out of the picture as soon as their "chapter" were over. Orphe, who is obviously the main lead, had surprisingly little screen time in the first volume and a half, making him feel under-developed. He remained the stereotypical "perfect prince," but we never got to see anything beyond that mask. His relationship with Erika also seemed to drop out of the sky; I really wanted to see a lot more lead-up and not just the "oh, I think I like her!" reaction. The pacing could've been a lot better, too, and the identity of her brother was pretty obvious (although I appreciated the attempts to throw in a few red herrings).

Subjectively, however, I... actually rather enjoyed this. Ha! Shallow characters, relationships and plot aside, this had all the trademarks of an otome game story - five gorgeous guys who are school idols and future political (and society) leaders to boot, and all of them gravitating towards a seemingly normal girl, who is chosen to be one of their aides. It's cheesy, but so, so much fun. The fact that it's set in an elite school and has a European setting is a bonus. It's probably a tribute to Kaori Yuki's character designs that I found all the boys interesting, too, despite the fact that they lacked depth. I suppose that's part of the charm of otome games and reverse harems; they're unrealistic and possibly quite silly, but there's something magnetic about a character being able to interact with multiple bishies of contrasting character types, all of whom are at least kindly towards her. Impossible scenario, but that's the whole point of a story, isn't it? The romance also ended satisfactorily, and the art is lovely.

All in all, Meine Liebe has a huge list of faults, but I think it can still be enjoyable providing you're in the mood for reading something of this type. It won't challenge your brain cells, but it's light, sweet and charming - for those after a nice combination of shoujo/otome game tropes, this might be your thing.

Was this comment useful?

baaad!!!

by Kaori9
15 years ago

Rating: 1.0 / 10.0

I read this because Yuki Kaori made character design. Fatal error! The most stupid reserve harem I ever read. It didn´t even start well, you knew the end from the start.

But I liked one scene: when she falls and that one guy says: "Mata?" (again?) --- INDEED, she is the most clumsy heroine that I ever saw, she falls at every fifth page. Brrrrr. really bad

Was this comment useful?

Predictable

by Johvalo
15 years ago

Rating: N/A

Man, this was one of the most predictable and boring manga I have ever read... Honestly, by the second chapter I already guessed who the brother was going to be, who the main girl was going to fall in love with, who the rival was going to be, how the plot was going to pan out, and this and that. It was just that predictable.
It's probably much more enjoyable if you've played the games and know the characters already.. I don't know how many of you are out there, though.
It was very much just a typical shoujo manga. Nothing more.
Props to the artist for creating awesome bishounen, though. Haha. That's one area they excel in.

Was this comment useful?

Cute.

by Doki
15 years ago

Rating: 7.0 / 10.0

I think this series would probably be most enjoyable for those who have watched the anime, the reason being that (in my opinion) the Strahl seemed OOC here and the manga does not devote a great deal to their character development, barely touching on what makes them unique.
Those who have watched the anime will of course know who is Erika's brother from the beginning (though it is rather obvious even in the first volume with no prior knowledge), but the story is cute and the art is wonderfully done.
My biggest issue with this series is that it seemed to be one of those stories that was desperately stretched out to four volumes, when I think just two would have been a stretch. There are a ton of "Why didn't Character X do Y?" or "Why didn't Character X just say Y sooner?" moments that would have shortened the manga and made it much more logical. Most unreasonable is that the heroine does not her brother's name though she can complex conversations she had with her brother.

In conclusion, if you're a fan of the Meine Liebe franchise and don't think too hard about the character's actions, this is a relatively enjoyable manga.

... Last updated 12 years ago

Was this comment useful?

So typical.

by LUEser
16 years ago

Rating: 1.0 / 10.0

One thing I hate about this manga is this fake positiveness in it. Half of the time, I get chills down my spine. I also don't like the way they were drawn, mainly because it doesn't match their ages.

Orpherus is such a typical "prince charming". I thought the cape was way overrated. I think the artist was trying to add that Knight look to him too but, fortunately, it backfired. In the beginning, he was like, "I would never like a girl like her" but it didn't show signs of his uninterest in her.

Ludwig is your typical "smart-aleck" dark guy; in other words: the guy with the villain looks. It was actually sort of cool that he doesn't like Erika... It was cool UNTIL...he wanted to know her answer and then started showing that uncool smile.

Naoji is like the opposite of Eduard; a romance guy, which Eduard, on the other hand, isn't but still a nice-guy anyway. The two knows that Orpherus is Erika's brother; they're both smart, catches on quick... No comment on their appearances. Uh, no comment on Camus either.

Erika... The main character is like every other shoujo chick: Annoying, determined, strong-willed, loud, clumsy, "cute", and last but not least, has a positiveness that everyone just seems to love about her. I hate that kind protagonist more than anything.

The story is squeezed together. It's quick and, yes, straight-to-the-point, but very boring that way. Ludwig doesn't even start showing up until chapter 4 but that's when everyone else is unimportant and gets left out. Such a boring Shoujo book.

... Last updated 16 years ago

Was this comment useful?

Kyaaa

by shelleymallow
16 years ago

Rating: 9.7 / 10.0

My third language is German and that was actually the main reason why i wanted to read this manga.

I really liked all the high-class, elite school stuff that was going around in Meine Leibe because in other shoujo mangas where the girl attends an elite private highschool, it's so modern and it looks too... casual? Something you would say is cliché in mangas but Meine Liebe has a really good setting of a sort of enchanted like school.

I'm gonna say, all five King scholars are bishies (even the one who seems cold at first-haha his hair). Although the main character girl looks pretty but not the most prettiest character that could have suited this sotry (someone with a softer, elegant face-urgh thnking of Tanemura's drawings) I really liked her even more because of that. She's pretty confident in finding her brother, although in some parts of the story she does seem a little helpless, but i think she was acceptable to be cast out from the 'irritating, cliché shoujo characters'.

This manga is a short and sweet romance series that is very pretty and has a flowing story line.
Although i personally would liked to have wanted it to be longer to show her progress with the one she loves ^^ i cant be disappointed that it ended like this because it fitted in very well either way.

A recommended manga to read that is warm and charming (the hwaat guys that is..)

... Last updated 16 years ago

Was this comment useful?

Neverending Traumerei

by Disremembrance
16 years ago

Rating: N/A

Having been based on such a great music composition, this manga lives up to the great expectations. I enjoyed Meine Liebe, but felt that the 'prince' could have been warmer towards her, he seemed quite cold, even though he did rather come on to her.

Was this comment useful?

Strange o.o

by kujika
17 years ago

Rating: 8.0 / 10.0

Yuki Kaori-san's works are usually rather twisted in plot and art alike, like really cruel, original fairy tales. I often thought what kind of person she must be...

But Meine Liebe is just pretty much like an ordinary shoujo manga, I was so surprised!

Don't get me wrong, I like^^

Was this comment useful?

Pages (2) 2 ]