I know loads of people like this series, so my opinion probably won't be very useful anyhow. Anyway, I was initially intrigued by the truly clever and attentive protagonist -- it is extremely rare to find a female lead so mature in the way she thinks and analyses situations. She is also very attentive, and completely different from any other romance female lead I've ever read about; not only does... 4z3j31

I found it melodramatic, too unrealistic, filled with plot holes, and overly dependent on character tropes commonly observed in GL (cool, collected, dark-haired tsundere beauty; cute, bubbly, kind, straightforward blonde). But loads of other people seem to like it though, so maybe my GL tastes are just weird.

If you're looking for something which is the opposite of all the points I've mentioned...

Cliche "Alice in Wonderland" premise which has been overdone in so many manga, bland heroine with little personality (but then again, this "wish fulfilment" type heroine is typical of most reverse harem manga), and character tropes galore (each guy is basically just another trope straight out of TVTropes). But I guess I'm being unfair, as my criticisms could easily apply to many reverse harem (and...