Baka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
What part of the world would you like to see represented more in manga/anime?
North Africa
South Africa
East Asia (excluding Japan)
Central Asia
South Asia
Southeast Asia
North America
Central America
South America
Eastern Europe
Western Europe
Middle East
Oceania
Antarctica
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed
Forums

manga discussion 4y3j1v

You must be ed to post!
From
Message Body
Post #464613
Post #464613
 avatar
the mu...
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 1050

... there's no thread for this manga yet, so i'm gonna start one.there are many to discuss about this manga.. like the patrilineal-patrilocal culture and society.. or the location (possibly uzbekistan... i could be wrong)... the time line setting, somewhere at "the great game" i think.. and so on and so onknowing emma i believe kaoru mori is stuffing herself with as much knowledge about this area, this culture, and this particular time to come out with otoyomegatari...see, there's a lot to talk about.. 4g3o3x

so lets me start with:
why does it say josei on the genre? even though it's published in a seinen magazine (now checking emma if this happen there too)... to whoever put josei up there, what's your excuse?

i know there's a thread specially made to report this type of case, but i think it's a lot better to talk about it here, don't you think?

ps: something i just realize.. why is the default name is otome-katari? not otoyomegatari?


... Last edited by mu2020 14 years ago
Member


8 years ago
Posts: 2

Hi, I was hoping for this manga to be revived. Been ready this for years and the translation is quite slow. Hoping more readers would be interested on reading this amazing manga 🙂 Plus points for this manga is, Older women with younger guy 😀


 avatar
Freedom is life
Member


6 years ago
Posts: 185

I'm not sure why everybody is so focused on the relationship between the first two main characters when half the manga is about another guy travelling around, which was in my opinion way more interesting. In fact I think the author understood it would be lacking to only show the daily life of the two lovers and couldn't help using a background character to renew it.

Even the recents antics of Karluk and Amar are barely romantic at all, which is a nice change honestly. That and I hope the author drops the "new arc, new bride" because I personally found it quite redundant in comparison to Smith's travels, at some point, and there's so much more to talk of about that era than just "brides brides brides".


Member


5 years ago
Posts: 1

Well, what would be the sense of the manga title then? "Otoyomegatari" literally means "Brides Stories".

And it's obvious Mori always planned to make this manga about various people, she didn't study and traveled all Central Asia just to stay in Uzbekistan. Besides, there's a reason one of the genres is slice-of-life. Henry is our "gate" to that world, a point of view most of the readers can understand easier, so it's also a obvious choice to make him the one who introduces most of the stories to us.
The manga takes place in The Great Game Era (most probably in the 1860s), and now as of the latest arc things have gotten more serious folowing that. For the happiness of some and sadness of others. But there's no way you can please everyone, even a great mangaka like Kaoru Mori. 🙂
I'm loving it as much as I always did, just a little more nervous now, seeing as I've become quite attached to all the characters.


Post #799601
Post #799601
 avatar
Member


3 years ago
Posts: 1

faviroute manga ll time the haqq alwys win


You must be ed to post!