Baka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
Scanlator is starting to translate a completed series that has lots of extra side content sprinkled throughout the story. They should...
Translate in order of release regardless of main story vs. side content
Prioritize the main story then go back and translate the extras
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed
Forums

So just how good is this manga? 6q5o3d

You must be ed to post!
From
Message Body
 avatar
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 452

So like, just how good is this manga? In of overall story, don't care much for action. Is it worth reading? I can't bring myself to get past the cringe-inducing title but it seems to be highly rated so I'm tempted... a5747


 avatar
bishounen lover
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 445

So far it seems promising, I enjoyed it. But it's not very long yet, and I'm not familiar with the original novel. It isn't really action focused as much as kind of a mystery/psychological.

That being said it really depends on what kind of manga you like. It's not the type of manga that will appeal to everyone, but if you like this genre, you'll enjoy it.

Bottom line: it's only 13 chapters, just read it. You'll figure out if you like it pretty quickly.


 avatar
Sun Knight Grisia
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 15

The concept is very good. The character development of the main character progresses smoothly throughout and makes a really powerful setting for the story. The action does not occur all the time, rather the story is about the character's growth in both physical and mental stages as he struggles to overcome his trial. Recently, Hollywood had adapted a Westernized version of this manga named the Edge of Tomorrow. You can go watch this movie in theaters if you wish when it gets released, but personally I feel that by Hollywoodizing it they have lost various important parts of the story's character development and the serious situation that the protagonist is in. Rather the Americanized movie places greater emphasis on action, comedy, and fan-service than the manga.


________________

Sun Knight Grisia

Groups:
Japtem:
Currently Translating Ark(Novel)

Member


11 years ago
Posts: 302

Quote from FrostLord

The concept is very good. The character development of the main character progresses smoothly throughout and makes a really powerful setting for the story. The action does not occur all the time, rather the story is about the character's growth in both physical and mental stages as he struggles to overcome his trial. Recently, Hollywood had adapted a Westernized version of this manga named the Edge of Tomorrow. You can go watch this movie in theaters if you wish when it gets released, but personally I feel that by Hollywoodizing it they have lost various important parts of the story's character development and the serious situation that the protagonist is in. Rather the Americanized movie places greater emphasis on action, comedy, and fan-service than the manga.

How can you say that about a movie that hasn't even been released in theatres yet? Please don't use your own speculation and stereotyping as facts, especially when all the critic reviews for the movie seem to be really good.


 avatar
Slightly obscene
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 498

Quote from tart

How can you say that about a movie that hasn't even been released in theatres yet? Please don't use your own speculation and stereotyping as facts, especially when all the critic reviews for the movie seem to be really good.

Actually, the movie has been released in Europe already. The UK release is dated today, 30th of May. Here in Finland, it started rolling in theaters on the 28th. I had tickets booked for myself and my roomie for yesterday, but had to cancel since he had a rough day and didn't feel like going. Going to see it on Sunday instead.

And I highly doubt that the critics have been comparing the movie to the original novel. I'm inclined to think that most of the criticts aren't even aware of the novel and definitely haven't read it.


________________
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 302

Quote from Baalzebup

Actually, the movie has been released in Europe already. The UK release is dated today, 30th of May. Here in Finland, it started rolling in theaters on the 28th. I had tickets booked for myself and my roomie for yesterday, but had to cancel since he had a rough day and didn't feel like going. Going to see it on Sunday instead.

Oh I see, nevermind then.


Post #643412
Post #643412
 avatar
Member


11 years ago
Posts: 452

Okay, thanks for the peeps. Glad to know it's not just some boom boom bang bang story =3.


You must be ed to post!